Am I the only one, who, when reading articles like this one and this one, thinks: “oh how great it is to be able to raise children in the Netherlands”? Who doesn’t think that Western parents got it all wrong? The only one who is not at all impressed with the fact that a three-year old can use a knife or a mechete?
I am not American, but I just don’t understand they recent backlash against the way Americans raise the children. I get it that looking at other cultures may teach us something, but not everything can be transported into our culture, and secondly, why would it? I see a trend of books and articles and blogs devoted to criticizing the American (which often stands for Western) way of life and raising children. European parents are also shown to get it right, unless of course they are seen as part of the Western world and this is when they get it wrong. I think American parents do many things right. In fact, I think they’re awesome. However, there are many reasons I love raising my kids in the Western world and Europe in particular, and why I love Western parenting.
1) The obvious
Such as the fact that while we can still work on women’s and minority rights, most people living in the West will not be killed for having an education, for expressing their views openly, for being a woman, or for believing or not believing is something, or in general, being different. Such as the fact that even despite the crisis, the political situation is more or less stable. As the fact that my children can get an education, have access to fresh water, medicine and technology.
2) We are diverse
“The West” seems like such a unified concept, especially when it comes to criticising it. Western parents don’t sleep with their children, Western parents don’t carry their children, Western parents don’t care. Except the West is extremely diverse. I have friends who babywear and friends who breastfeed and friends who don’t. I have friends from all around the Western world and they will be the first to tell just you how diverse we are. In Europe, all countries have their own traditions and customs on raising children, and that is awesome! Our diversity is our greatest gift. On top of that, they will come across many different people from different backgrounds, including gay parents, childless couples, parents who adopted, and of course, parents from many cultural and racial backgrounds.
3) We are open to criticism and we want to learn
The fact that such critical articles even exist and gain recognition so quickly, pretty much proves my point. Because if we weren’t so open to criticism, we wouldn’t welcome these articles and they wouldn’t spread so fast. We think a lot about raising our children. We try to look for an answer that suits us. We try to learn from other cultures and incorporate their methods into our everyday lives. We think of how our parents raised us and try to do better. We really want to learn. We question everything and try to find our own ways. What is so bad about that?
4) We give our children roots and wings
It seems to me (and please correct me if I am wrong) that other cultures raise their children in a more unified manner. Every parent does the same, because the community requires it. Our children, on the other hand, have choices in what they want to become. We want the children to learn about other cultures and accept them. We want our children to find the right balance between respecting us as parents and respecting themselves, between keeping their connections to families and finding their own ways.
5) We want it all and we want it now!
We may come across as entitled and privileged and arrogant, but we feel very strongly about our rights. Not only do we want everybody to have their rights, we want everybody to have all rights and have them right now! We think big. We dream big. When we want something, we will fight for it. We believe that we are able to do it all. We want to work and spend time with the children and instead of giving up on our dreams we try to change the system to accommodate it. While this can cause us trouble, I still believe it takes courage.
6) We believe in individual choices
The one thing I particularly love about living in the West is the freedom of choice to do what I please unless I endanger somebody else’s freedom. We truly believe that it is our right to be happy and we should do everything to pursuit our happiness. Egoistic? Yes. But I believe that egoistic decisions are not always bad, because following rules just to please society or because we fear judgment may make us unhappy. Paradoxically, unhappy members of society are not good members of society. Does it make sense? We have opportunities, which can cause us to feel uncomfortable. But as I say: it is better to have too many choices than to have no choices at all.
7) We grow good people and we enjoy being with our children
Just like parents everywhere, we just want the best for our children. Just like everywhere else, our children grow up to be good, caring, involved people. One thing that books like to criticize about Western parents is that they don’t allow the children to play by themselves. It is only me who think that the reason that we do so much with our children is the fact that we have so much fun with them? That spending time with our children, be it playing, teaching, running, laughing or anything else is actually fun and we do it because we want to and not because we have to? We are not authority figures and we don’t strive to be ones. Instead, we want to be friends and advocates and confidants of our children. We do not expect our children to behave; instead we want them to be themselves.
I believe that I am lucky that I can raise my children here. I think the West in general and Europe in particular are extremely child-friendly- with a few exceptions, but life is so good here.